Buyers arrive with a projector quote

Almost every dome conversation starts the same way. The client has a projector price in hand, usually for a 30 to 60 square metre surface, and asks why LED is three times that. The honest answer for that size is: it is three times that, and a projector is a reasonable choice.

The projector argument gets thin in one specific situation. The dome is a public exhibit, people walk underneath it, and one visitor standing in the beam puts a shadow on the wall. No lens, no brightness rating, no lens shift fixes that. That is the point where LED becomes the only option rather than the expensive option.

A dome is the top of a sphere, and the top is where the cost hides

Take a 6 m dome. The arc at its equator is 18.8 m long, at 30 degrees up from the rim it is 9.4 m, and at 15 degrees from the pole it is 4.9 m. The surface keeps shrinking toward the top while the number of boards you need per square metre does not.

You cannot fit a standard half-metre cabinet into a 4.9 m circle without cutting it, and every cut is a new board type. So the top 20% of the surface ends up carrying close to 40% of the tooling. Same lit area, several times the engineering.

A spherical cap LED screen photographed from below, its lit face carrying a wildflower scene
A cap seen from underneath. The lit ellipse is the whole screen, and the pole at its centre is where a dome master either resolves or turns into a blur.

Two ways to finish the pole, and one of them is dishonest

Option one keeps going with narrower gores until the last ring is about 200 mm, then closes with a small cap. Option two stops the screen at 15 or 20 degrees and puts a trim ring or a black panel there.

Option two is cheaper and it is the one that quietly ruins the room. The zenith is where the 3D illusion resolves. Cut it off and what you have built is a curved cinema screen that people look up at, not a place they stand inside. It should be a decision made on the drawing, not a surprise discovered in the invoice.

The number that sets the price is board types, not square metres

Inside one latitude band, every wedge is identical, so a band is one type that repeats all the way around. The count is roughly the arc length divided by the board height, plus the specials at the pole and the rim. A 170 square metre P3 bowl lands around 25 to 35 types. A 76 square metre P4 dome can need 40 to 60, because a P4 board is shorter and the same arc takes more bands.

Each type carries a mask or mould, an SMT program, a first-article check and a spare stock line. That is why the smaller, finer dome in this example is the more expensive one per square metre, which surprises people every time.

A dome does not play video, it plays a dome master

Flatten a normal video file onto a dome and the pole turns into a smeared pinwheel. The correct input is a dome master, rendered for that exact cap angle, usually as a fisheye frame. Most clients have never heard of it and assume it is a conversion.

It is not a conversion, it is a render, and the numbers bite. A 170 square metre hemisphere has a half-circumference near 23 m. A 4K master across 23 m gives one pixel every 6 mm. The screen behind it is P3, so half the resolution you paid for never arrives. If the content matters, the master gets rendered at native resolution, and that line item belongs in the budget from day one.

The rim is where visitors stand

People do not stand in the middle of a bowl, they stand at the edge and look in. That is a grazing angle, 70 degrees or more off the surface normal, and brightness there is a third of what it is at the centre. Any demo done facing the middle of the screen is a demo of the wrong viewing position.

The rim is also the only edge a visitor can touch. A 100 mm border mask, a rolled trim and a sealed edge cost very little and are the difference between an exhibit and a construction site. The photograph everyone takes is of that rim.

Hanging two and a half tonnes from somebody else's roof

A 76 square metre indoor dome is around 2.5 t of screen, frame and trim, before you add a catwalk. The roof structure was designed by someone else for a different load case, and the structural engineer who signs off is not the LED supplier.

Get the load drawing out early. The two questions that stop projects are whether the roof can take a point load where the hangers want to land, and whether anyone can reach the top of the dome after handover without scaffolding.

What I would write into the RFQ

Four lines. Brightness measured at 60 degrees off axis, not at the centre. Board type count, and the priced spare list per type. Who renders the dome master, at what resolution, and whether that is inside the contract. How the pole is finished and how a module at the top is replaced.

None of those four appear in a standard quotation, and each of them has moved a project budget by more than the price difference between two suppliers.